Pairing heap

Difference in differences (sometimes 'Difference-in-Differences', 'DID', or 'DD') is a technique used in econometrics that measures the effect of a treatment at a given period in time. It is often used to measure the change induced by a particular treatment or event, though it may be subject to certain biases (mean reversion bias, etc.). In contrast to a within-subjects estimate of the treatment effect (that measures the difference in an outcome after and before treatment) or a between-subjects estimate of the treatment effect (that measures the difference in an outcome between the treatment and control groups), the DID estimator represents the difference between the pre-post, within-subjects differences of the treatment and control groups.

Formal Definition

Consider the model

$y_{ist}~=~\gamma _{s}+\lambda _{t}+\delta D_{st}+\epsilon _{ist}$

where $y_{ist}$ is the dependent variable for individual $i$, given $s$ and $t$. The dimensions $s$ and $t$ may for example be state and time. $\gamma _{s}$ and $\lambda _{t}$ is then the vertical intercept for $s$ and $t$ respectively. $D_{st}$ is a dummy variable indicating treatment status, $\delta$ is the treatment effect, and $\epsilon _{ist}$ is an error term.

Let

${\overline {y}}_{st}~=~{\frac {1}{n}}\sum _{i=1}^{n}y_{ist}$,

${\overline {\gamma }}_{s}~=~{\frac {1}{n}}\sum _{i=1}^{n}\gamma _{s}~=~\gamma _{s}$,

${\overline {\lambda }}_{t}~=~{\frac {1}{n}}\sum _{i=1}^{n}\lambda _{t}~=~\lambda _{t}$,

${\overline {D}}_{st}~=~{\frac {1}{n}}\sum _{i=1}^{n}D_{st}~=~D_{st}$,

${\overline {\epsilon }}_{st}~=~{\frac {1}{n}}\sum _{i=1}^{n}\epsilon _{ist}$,

and suppose for simplicity that $s=1,2$ and $t=1,2$. Then

$({\overline {y}}_{11}-{\overline {y}}_{12})-({\overline {y}}_{21}-{\overline {y}}_{22})$

$=\left[(\gamma _{1}+\lambda _{1}+\delta D_{11}+{\overline {\epsilon }}_{11})-(\gamma _{1}+\lambda _{2}+\delta D_{12}+{\overline {\epsilon }}_{12})\right]-\left[(\gamma _{2}+\lambda _{1}+\delta D_{21}+{\overline {\epsilon }}_{21})-(\gamma _{2}-\lambda _{2}+\delta D_{22}+{\overline {\epsilon }}_{22})\right]$

$=\delta (D_{11}-D_{12})+\delta (D_{22}-D_{21})+{\overline {\epsilon }}_{11}-{\overline {\epsilon }}_{12}+{\overline {\epsilon }}_{22}-{\overline {\epsilon }}_{21}$.

The strict exogeneity assumption then implies that

$E\left[({\overline {y}}_{11}-{\overline {y}}_{12})-({\overline {y}}_{21}-{\overline {y}}_{22})\right]~=~\delta (D_{11}-D_{12})+\delta (D_{22}-D_{21})$.

Without loss of generality, assume that $D_{22}=1$ and $D_{11}=D_{12}=D_{21}=0$, giving the DID estimator

${\hat {\delta }}~=~({\overline {y}}_{11}-{\overline {y}}_{12})-({\overline {y}}_{21}-{\overline {y}}_{22})$,

which can be interpreted as the treatment effect of the treatment indicated by $D_{st}$.

Assumptions

Illustration of the parallel trend assumption

All the assumptions of the OLS model apply equally to DID. In addition, DID requires a parallel trend assumption. The parallel trend assumption says that $\lambda _{2}-\lambda _{1}$ are the same in both $s=1$ and $s=2$. Given that the formal definition above accurately represents reality, this assumption automatically holds. However, a model with $\lambda _{st}~:~\lambda _{22}-\lambda _{21}\neq \lambda _{12}-\lambda _{11}$ may well be more realistic.

As illustrated to the right, the treatment effect is the difference between the observed value of y and what the value of y would have been with parallel trends, had there been no treatment. The Achilles' heel of DID is when something other than the treatment changes in one group but not the other at the same time as the treatment, implying a violation of the parallel trend assumption.

To guarantee the accuracy of the DID estimate, the composition of individuals of the two groups is assumed to remain unchanged over time. When using a DID model, various issues that may compromise the results, such as autocorrelation and Ashenfelter dips, must be considered and dealt with.

Implementation

The DID method can be implemented according to the table below, where the lower right cell is the DID estimator.

$y_{st}$	$s=2$	$s=1$	Difference
$t=2$	$y_{22}$	$y_{12}$	$y_{12}-y_{22}$
$t=1$	$y_{21}$	$y_{11}$	$y_{11}-y_{21}$
Change	$y_{21}-y_{22}$	$y_{11}-y_{12}$	$(y_{11}-y_{21})-(y_{12}-y_{22})$

Running a regression analysis gives the same result. Consider the OLS model

$y~=~\beta _{0}+\beta _{1}T+\beta _{2}S+\beta _{3}(T\cdot S)+\varepsilon$

where $T$ is a dummy variable for $t=2$, and $S$ is a dummy variable for $s=2$. The composite variable $(T\cdot S)$ is then a dummy variable indicating when $S=T=1$. Although it is not shown rigorously here, it turns out that the estimates in this model are

${\hat {\beta }}_{0}~=~(y~|~T=0,~S=0)$

${\hat {\beta }}_{1}~=~(y~|~T=1,~S=0)-(y~|~T=0,~S=0)$

${\hat {\beta }}_{2}~=~(y~|~T=0,~S=1)-(y~|~T=0,~S=0)$

${\hat {\beta }}_{3}~=~[(y~|~T=1,~S=1)-(y~|~T=0,~S=1)]-[(y~|~T=1,~S=0)-(y~|~T=0,~S=0)]$,

which is equivalent to

${\hat {\beta }}_{3}~=~(y_{11}-y_{21})-(y_{12}-y_{22})$.

But this is the expression for the treatment effect that was given in the formal definition and in the above table.

Card & Krueger (1994) example

Consider one of the most famous DID studies, the Card and Krueger article on minimum wage in New Jersey, published in 1994. Card and Krueger compared employment in the fast food sector in New Jersey and in Pennsylvania, in February 1992 and in November 1992, after New Jersey's minimum wage rose from $4.25 to $5.05 in April 1992. Observing a change in employment in New Jersey only, before and after the treatment, would fail to control for omitted variables such as weather and macroeconomic conditions of the region. By including Pennsylvania as a control in a difference-in-differences model, any bias caused by variables common to New Jersey and Pennsylvania are implicitly controlled for, even when these variables are unobserved. Assuming that New Jersey and Pennsylvania have parallel trends over time, Pennsylvania's change in employment can be interpreted as the change New Jersey would have experienced, had they not increased the minimum wage, and vice versa. The evidence suggested that the increased minimum wage did not induce an increase in unemployment in New Jersey, as standard economic theory would suggest. The table below shows Card & Krueger's estimates of the treatment effect on employment, measured as FTEs (or Full-time equivalents). Keeping in mind that the finding is controversial, Card and Krueger estimate that the $0.80 minimum wage increase in New Jersey lead to a 2.76 FTE increase in employment.

	New Jersey	Pennsylvania	Difference
February	20.44	23.33	-2.89
November	21.03	21.17	-0.14
Change	0.59	-2.16	2.76

Critics

In 2004, the question "How Much Should We Trust Differences-in-Differences Estimates?" was asked in an article with the same name, and apparently the answer is "not all that much." It is worth noting however that this is only the case if DiD is employed without considering the auto-correlation in calculating the standard errors. Most papers that employ Difference-in-Differences estimation use many years of data and focus on serially correlated outcomes but ignore that the resulting standard errors are inconsistent, leading to serious over-estimation of t-statistics and significance levels. These conventional DID standard errors severely understate the standard deviation of the estimators: we find an "effect" significant at the 5 percent level for up to 45 percent of the placebo interventions. To alleviate this problem two corrections based on asymptotic approximation of the variance-covariance matrix work well for moderate numbers of states and one correction that collapses the time series information into a "pre" and "post" period and explicitly takes into account the effective sample size works well even for small numbers of states.

See also

• Design of experiments
• Average treatment effect

References

43 year old Petroleum Engineer Harry from Deep River, usually spends time with hobbies and interests like renting movies, property developers in singapore new condominium and vehicle racing. Constantly enjoys going to destinations like Camino Real de Tierra Adentro.

Further reading

• One of the biggest reasons investing in a Singapore new launch is an effective things is as a result of it is doable to be lent massive quantities of money at very low interest rates that you should utilize to purchase it. Then, if property values continue to go up, then you'll get a really high return on funding (ROI). Simply make sure you purchase one of the higher properties, reminiscent of the ones at Fernvale the Riverbank or any Singapore landed property Get Earnings by means of Renting
  
  In its statement, the singapore property listing - website link, government claimed that the majority citizens buying their first residence won't be hurt by the new measures. Some concessions can even be prolonged to chose teams of consumers, similar to married couples with a minimum of one Singaporean partner who are purchasing their second property so long as they intend to promote their first residential property. Lower the LTV limit on housing loans granted by monetary establishments regulated by MAS from 70% to 60% for property purchasers who are individuals with a number of outstanding housing loans on the time of the brand new housing purchase. Singapore Property Measures - 30 August 2010 The most popular seek for the number of bedrooms in Singapore is 4, followed by 2 and three. Lush Acres EC @ Sengkang
  
  Discover out more about real estate funding in the area, together with info on international funding incentives and property possession. Many Singaporeans have been investing in property across the causeway in recent years, attracted by comparatively low prices. However, those who need to exit their investments quickly are likely to face significant challenges when trying to sell their property – and could finally be stuck with a property they can't sell. Career improvement programmes, in-house valuation, auctions and administrative help, venture advertising and marketing, skilled talks and traisning are continuously planned for the sales associates to help them obtain better outcomes for his or her shoppers while at Knight Frank Singapore. No change Present Rules
  
  Extending the tax exemption would help. The exemption, which may be as a lot as $2 million per family, covers individuals who negotiate a principal reduction on their existing mortgage, sell their house short (i.e., for lower than the excellent loans), or take part in a foreclosure course of. An extension of theexemption would seem like a common-sense means to assist stabilize the housing market, but the political turmoil around the fiscal-cliff negotiations means widespread sense could not win out. Home Minority Chief Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) believes that the mortgage relief provision will be on the table during the grand-cut price talks, in response to communications director Nadeam Elshami. Buying or promoting of blue mild bulbs is unlawful.
  
  A vendor's stamp duty has been launched on industrial property for the primary time, at rates ranging from 5 per cent to 15 per cent. The Authorities might be trying to reassure the market that they aren't in opposition to foreigners and PRs investing in Singapore's property market. They imposed these measures because of extenuating components available in the market." The sale of new dual-key EC models will even be restricted to multi-generational households only. The models have two separate entrances, permitting grandparents, for example, to dwell separately. The vendor's stamp obligation takes effect right this moment and applies to industrial property and plots which might be offered inside three years of the date of buy. JLL named Best Performing Property Brand for second year running
  
  The data offered is for normal info purposes only and isn't supposed to be personalised investment or monetary advice. Motley Fool Singapore contributor Stanley Lim would not personal shares in any corporations talked about. Singapore private home costs increased by 1.eight% within the fourth quarter of 2012, up from 0.6% within the earlier quarter. Resale prices of government-built HDB residences which are usually bought by Singaporeans, elevated by 2.5%, quarter on quarter, the quickest acquire in five quarters. And industrial property, prices are actually double the levels of three years ago. No withholding tax in the event you sell your property. All your local information regarding vital HDB policies, condominium launches, land growth, commercial property and more
  
  There are various methods to go about discovering the precise property. Some local newspapers (together with the Straits Instances ) have categorised property sections and many local property brokers have websites. Now there are some specifics to consider when buying a 'new launch' rental. Intended use of the unit Every sale begins with 10 p.c low cost for finish of season sale; changes to 20 % discount storewide; follows by additional reduction of fiftyand ends with last discount of 70 % or extra. Typically there is even a warehouse sale or transferring out sale with huge mark-down of costs for stock clearance. Deborah Regulation from Expat Realtor shares her property market update, plus prime rental residences and houses at the moment available to lease Esparina EC @ Sengkang

External links

• How Does Charitable Giving Respond to Incentives and Income? Dynamic Panel Estimates Accounting for Predictable Changes in Taxation, National Bureau of Economic Research, July 2005
• T. Conley and C. Taber, "Inference with "Difference in Differences" with a Small Number of Policy Changes", National Bureau of Economic Research, July 2005
• Difference in Difference Estimation, Healthcare Economist website